Skip to main content
  1. Blog./

The Paper Shield: Why You Need Invention Disclosure Documents

·1133 words·6 mins·
Ben Schmidt
Author
I am going to help you build the impossible.

The Due Diligence Nightmare

#

Imagine the scene. You are sitting in a glass walled conference room. The coffee is cold. The air conditioning is humming a little too loudly.

Across from you sits a team of investors. They love your product. They believe in the market fit. The valuation numbers look exactly like what you hoped they would.

Then the lawyers walk in.

They do not care about your vision. They care about chain of title. They want to know exactly who wrote the core algorithm that powers your platform. You tell them it was a mix. It was you. It was your cofounder. It was a freelance developer you hired in the early days. It was an advisor who sketched a schematic on a napkin.

The lawyers stop smiling.

They ask for the paper trail. They want to see the assignment of rights. They want to know if that freelancer signed a specific document transferring the intellectual property to the company. They want to know if the advisor formally waived their rights to the invention.

You realize you do not have these documents.

This is the moment where deals die. It is the moment where leverage shifts from the founder to the investor. It is a structural failure that could have been prevented years ago with a boring piece of paper.

That paper is called an Invention Disclosure Document.

What is an Invention Disclosure Document?

#

An Invention Disclosure Document, or IDD, is an internal form. It is not a patent application. It is not a public filing. It is a business record.

Its purpose is to establish a timeline and a roster.

When a new feature, process, or mechanism is created within your company, the IDD captures the details. It asks simple questions. What is the invention? Who contributed to it? When was it conceived? When was it first tested?

From a scientific perspective, it acts as a laboratory notebook for the entire organization. It creates a definitive date of conception. In the world of intellectual property, dates matter. Being able to prove you had the idea on a specific Tuesday can be the difference between owning a patent and infringing on one.

But the true value of the IDD is not just about dates. It is about people.

It forces a conversation about who actually did the work.

The Employee Assumption

#

There is a common assumption among first time founders regarding employees. The logic goes like this. I pay them a salary. Therefore, I own everything they think of.

This is generally true if you have robust employment agreements. However, general employment agreements are broad. They cast a wide net.

An IDD is specific. It ties a specific human to a specific output.

When an employee fills out an IDD, they are formally stating that they created this specific thing in the scope of their employment. They are listing their co-inventors. They are acknowledging the company’s ownership in real time.

This becomes vital years later. Employees leave. They move to competitors. They start their own firms.

If an ex-employee claims they invented your core technology on their own time or on their own equipment, the IDD serves as evidence to the contrary. It is a document they signed while employed, describing the work they did for you.

It removes ambiguity. Ambiguity is expensive.

The Contractor Loophole

#

The risk increases exponentially when you move outside the payroll.

Startups often rely on contractors, dev shops, or freelancers to build early versions of the product. The relationship feels transactional. You pay an invoice. They send code.

But intellectual property laws vary by jurisdiction. In many places, paying for work does not automatically transfer the copyright or patent rights of the invention. It might only grant you a license to use it.

The creator retains ownership.

Imagine your startup takes off. That freelancer who wrote the initial backend code realizes the value of what they built. Without a clear assignment of invention, they could claim ownership of the underlying IP.

Requiring contractors to file an IDD for significant contributions changes the dynamic. It acts as a receipt for the intellectual property, not just the labor. It forces the issue of ownership to be resolved immediately, rather than during a lawsuit five years later.

The Advisor Trap

#

This is perhaps the most insidious category because it feels the safest.

You have mentors. You have advisors. You have smart friends you meet for coffee to brainstorm. You draw on whiteboards. They suggest a pivot in the architecture. It is a breakthrough moment.

Who owns that idea?

If that advisor is not under a contract that specifically assigns inventions to your company, they might own it. Or at the very least, they might be a co-inventor.

If you file a patent later without naming them, the patent could be invalid. If you do name them, and they haven’t assigned the rights to you, they own a piece of your patent.

Using an IDD process helps you catalog these interactions. If an advisor contributes a patentable idea, the IDD flags it. You can then ensure the proper assignment documents are signed while everyone is still friendly and the equity value is still low.

We must ask ourselves hard questions here. How many casual conversations have influenced your product roadmap? How many lines of code were pasted in by a helpful friend? Are those contributions secured, or are they liabilities waiting to surface?

Implementing the Discipline

#

You might worry that this adds bureaucracy. You might think this slows down the build.

That is a valid concern. You do not want to stifle creativity with red tape. However, the IDD does not need to be complex. It can be a simple digital form. It does not need to be filed for every minor bug fix. It should be reserved for novel features, new algorithms, or significant design changes.

The goal is not to create paperwork. The goal is to create assets.

An undocumented invention is an abstract concept. A documented invention, with a clear chain of title, is an asset that can be valued, sold, or protected.

Let us return to the conference room from the beginning.

The lawyers ask for the chain of title. You open a folder. You produce the Invention Disclosure Documents. You show the signatures from the employees. You show the assignment from the contractor who built the prototype. You show the waiver from the advisor.

The timeline is clear. The ownership is absolute.

The lawyers nod. The investors smile. The coffee is still cold, but the deal is done.

Building a company is about more than just the product. It is about building the foundation that allows the product to exist safely. The IDD is a cornerstone of that foundation.